Offenbach & Frankfurt reject change in trade tax calculation
21.07.2023
The treasurers of the two neighboring cities of Offenbach and Frankfurt, Martin Wilhelm and Dr. Bastian Bergerhoff, say "No!" to plans by the Federal Ministry of Finance to change the calculation of trade tax. The finance department heads jointly reject the Federal Ministry of Finance's draft Growth Opportunities Act. This is because it would suspend the minimum profit tax at the expense of municipal finances. Despite the very different conditions, the two cities would potentially be hit hard; both the financially strong metropolis of Frankfurt and the small city of Offenbach are threatened with significant revenue losses as a result of the plan - at a time when prices are rising significantly.
"The implementation of the planned regulation would lead to considerable losses in municipal trade tax revenue for the municipalities as a whole. This would be a bitter and simply unacceptable setback for many cities and municipalities that are making considerable efforts to attract and retain companies," says Frankfurt's City Treasurer Dr. Bastian Bergerhoff. "Tax cuts at the expense of local authorities are unacceptable in view of the burdens placed on local authorities by rising costs, rising interest rates and the energy and transport transition to be implemented in local authorities in particular. If the law is passed, the cities and municipalities must be compensated accordingly," adds Offenbach's city treasurer Martin Wilhelm. Both remind us to adhere to the principle of connectivity: "If the Federal Minister of Finance wants to relieve the burden on companies, he can do so, but not at the expense of the municipalities' ability to act," the two finance directors agree.
Revenue shortfall of 1.9 billion euros looming
Across Germany, local authorities are facing a shortfall in revenue of 1.9 billion euros. In 2022, municipal coffers received 70 billion euros in trade tax. This enabled essential public services to be maintained. If 1.9 billion euros were now to be saved, this would mean a drop in the required revenue of -2.7 percent - with a current inflation rate of 6.4 percent.
With their clear "no" to the plans of Federal Finance Minister Christian Lindner, the two city treasurers are aligning themselves with the positions of the Hessian and German Association of Cities. They had already warned of high municipal revenue losses and emphasized that the minimum profit tax on trade tax is indispensable as a municipal tax. The draft of the Growth Opportunities Act is currently being coordinated by the departments. The Federal Cabinet is expected to discuss it on August 16, 2023.
"Our cities need trade tax to be able to finance good infrastructure and appropriate local services for citizens and businesses. Cutting back here cannot be in the interests of the federal government either," Wilhelm and Dr. Bergerhoff agree. "This law must not come into force without appropriate compensation."